Social networking–growing pains
Tuesday, July 24th, 2007There’s some feathers being ruffled these days over Facebook’s closed API. They think it’s “bad for the web” because it’s just “like AOL was”. This is strange because AOL was an ISP with its own browser that you had to use. Places like Facebook (”fb”) are just websites. They have no control over your connection nor the browser you use to surf them–they’re two completely different animals.
What the critics are saying is that because apps can only be built for fb and not used anywhere else on the web, this “walled garden” contributes nothing to the advancement of the net as a social system.
Apparently the critics haven’t noticed the massive amount of spam everyone gets every fucking day on their myspace page and blogs, or the freaks and stalkers wandering around looking for fresh meat, or the lack of useful social utilities that keeps me in the know or make it easy for me to reconnect with my college buddies. Facebook is a sign of things to come–we will eventually make the internet a white-list-based network. See, because fb is walled off, I never have to deal with unsolicited messages, spam comments (though Google is doing an excellent job here now), and my lady friends aren’t always being harassed by total strangers, plus fb tells me when something happens in my friends’ lives that they want me to know about.
I want walled gardens because the vast majority of the web is full of shit I don’t want. Without the walls, I don’t have a reliable means to keep that shit off me. Granted, I would prefer to have an open standard that doesn’t dish out ads (as ignorable as fb’s are) that I can augment with someone else’s spiffy app, but that requires a fundamental change in the way we connect to the net. So for now, places like fb and LinkedIn are necessary.